 tonegrill on Winchester is impressive enough, if nothing else, because it finally brings the underused Winchester Hotel space to life; but the main attraction of this dining room is that it's more interactive than you might have initially bargained for. More than just a clever name, an eponymous stone grill is brought to your table alongside your entrée. Your raw entrée. The idea is for you to grill your entrée on the sizzling hot rock to your specs a la Korean Grill House.
This method, according to our hyperbole-driven waiter, sears in the juices and nutrients, enhancing the full flavours and tenderness of the food. While the idea is inspiring, the implementation is tiresome. And, it should be noted, is not for the impatient.
Nonetheless, Stonegrill Chef Tim McHugh does a super job with tapas plates. Grilled calamari, for example, is a classic, and one we know well, but so satisfying when well-executed. And these little gems, stuffed with chorizo sausage, are the best of the lot. Even the little dose of black olive tapenade reigns supreme.
The spicy chicken ($8.00), another solid choice, is a little homemade dim sum paired with buttery soy-plum sake sauce. The steamed mango-injected pillow is appropriately spicy, as advertised. Similarly, McHugh brightens their dense, moist and satiny house-made Cabbagetown rolls ($12.00) with a quivering spoonful of toasted sesame mayo; while the added tomato concasse is striking addition, the crispy rolls need something more, maybe just salt. A plate of three mini burgers is a great little composition; the entire table hovering over the cutest baby burgers in town, stealing the thunder away from the less cute, but much more quality-driven plates.
|
51 Winchester Street, Toronto, ON.
4 Reader Reviews
This is what happens when become over-confident after insinuating yourself into a community as the rich aunt. I've written before that this was a great place. Well, I've been back a number of times since then and it's going right downhill. Not only are the prices for the simple items just unrealistic, the mains are overzealous and do not meet my expectations. I also notice there is a change in the kitchen staff, and the same with the servers. The servers are becoming arrogant and somewhat "this is just a job" sloppy attitude. I don't see the same faces in the kitchen, and there seems to be a strained atmosphere overall. The food has become boring. One of my favourite starters, the gnocchi, is pasty and not as flavourful as before. Recently I tried the bison ribeye again and it was tough and tasted a little liverish. I might give it another chance, but the last 3 times have been a disappointment. When you bring your concerns to the management, a free cognac or licquor is slight compensation.
Wendy's Rating: 2 Stars |
 |
Boy oh Boy oh Boy - what a wonderful meal every time! I had the chance to eat at the Stonegrill since it first came to Cabbagetown and have been very impressed with the food, cooking on the stones, the ambiance and friendliness of the staff. I've had a couple of brunches on Sundays and dinners several times. But I was worried when there was a change in the kitchen when Chef Tim left and I was wondering what would happen. Sous Chefs Anthony and Erin took over AND THEY ARE AMAZING! Especially this young man Anthony. I freaked when I found out he's only 22! And Erin is great too. So far I've eaten there about 8 times and cannot complain about a single thing. I seem to get the same servers most of the time (Jo & Ant) and they make my day! They are so entertaining and attentive without being smothering. The owners should count their blessings that they have such great staff. Keep up the good work everyone. I'll be back again and again.
Wendy Symchisin's Rating: 4 Stars |
 |
Stonegrill on Winchester is very, very good, the food is excellent, and the service is very good when not flagrantly flamboyant or in-your-face cutesy, or on those occasions you don’t get served by a waitress who simply doesn’t give a damn. But what a mistake they are making on New Years.
You can have a steak there on any day for $29 or $30....but a $95 menu on New Years Eve sounds wild and out of whack! For a neighborhood eatery? They are NOT the Four Seasons! So many restaurants try to rob the eyes out of the regulars on New Years...and the $95 doesn't include taxes, or tips, or wine with dinner. So 2 people will have to spend $250 just to sit down before they order so much as a coffee. And NO LIVE MUSIC! So since when did a sorbet for palate cleansing count as a FULL COURSE? And who wants a 5-course meal there anyway? We usually share fries, and calamari, and mashed potatoes. So suddenly it's the RITZ? Get real. If the owners don't even understand what there own restaurant is, and their own market they obviously haven't got a clue. Not to mention respect for regular customers. If you price New Years out of reach of the regulars you've just pissed them off for supporting you and embarrassed them for inquiring. You drive them away. And make yourselves the laughing stock in the community at the same time. People talk, and Cabbagetown is only several hundred houses. $95? 5 courses? Who needs you? Greed! The city has buried enough greedy owners. I won't go back just because of the nerve of it. At that markup, McDonald's would make a fortune on New Years with $20 Big Macs and $15 fries! Maybe not. No one would go there either if they tried! At least they know their customers!
STONEGRILL, hang a sign outside that reads 'OUR REGULARS AND OTHER FOOLS WELCOME ON SPECIAL NIGHTS WHEN WE CAN ROB YOU BLIND'
No one wants a 5 course meal from you. No one wants a fancy meal from you. No one wants your earlier $65 meal either, because we’d have to leave by 8:30, and no one parties at 8:30 and keeps on drinking. Good luck! I’ll pass by your window and chuckle at your empty room!
95.00 price per person
14.25 tax @ 15%
17.10 tip @ 18%
126.35 Total EACH.
252.70 / COUPLE. Digusting!
And I bet you think we should jump up and down at the prospect of a glass of sparkling wine included you bought at $12 a bottle or less!
Good riddance!
Wayne,
Your former customer who has been there over a half dozen times.
p.s. with all the people who work there, isn’t there even one person who said this isn’t a good idea? That this has nothing to do with what Stonegrill is about? Fools! Spread the word!
Wayne's Rating: 4 Stars |
 |
Great concept, welcome to the neighbourhood!
Lydia C.'s Rating: 4 Stars |
 |
Voice your opinion! Submit a reader review for Stonegrill on Winchester. Click here
|
|
|
|
Stonegrill on Winchester |
51 Winchester Street, Toronto, ON.
416-967-6565
Cabbagetown
Contemporary
Restaurant
Mon - Fri 4:00pm-2:00am Sat: 11:00am-2:00am Sun: 11:00am-11:00pm
$$$ (Within Reach)
Master Card Visa American Express |
Related Restaurants |
|
|
|
|