Prime, Toronto

Martiniboys
Martiniboys Toronto Toronto Restaurants, Toronto Dining Guide Toronto Clubs and Nightlife Toronto Citystock Toronto Hotels Toronto Hot Tickets Toronto Galleries Toronto Theatre Toronto Movies Toronto Products
MBO Toronto :: Toronto Restaurants & Dining Guide
  • Prime

    Prime: cute or clichéd name for a restaurant, depending on how you look at it. I’d say the same for the menu at this relatively recent Windsor Arms restaurant, dedicated to offering steakhouse fare with a sense of seasonality at white-topped table prices.

    Right off the bat, special mention should go to the hotel’s über update of the two-room space, which now captures the best aspects of the room in alternating tones of tan leather and dark woods. Designers have thoroughly explored the space, giving slick and shiny vigor to the square footage that was previously the ignorable Club 22 - a burning fireplace and a display of paintings by Canadian artist Charles Pachter - to create a modern steakhouse look and feel.

    In the kitchen, Chef Stephen Ricci does his part to steer his efforts in the opposite direction of Windsor Arms’ disappointing past, concentrating less on hotel-restaurant-friendly noshes and embracing a more complete steakhouse mindset, right down to preparing steaks in an 1,800° infrared broiler.

    How does it hold up? When it's good, it's great. You can't be displeased by tender, subtly spiced tuna sashimi on a soba noodle salad, or the cool, nicely plump, kataif wrapped jumbo shrimp with celery mayonnaise. Nor the appetizer plate of organic beets with watercress and chèvre; tossed together haphazardly, this dish is business-class airline food. Arranged in Ricci’s fashion, it is close to art.

    One evening, with several friends in tow and nearly every seat in the restaurant occupied by suspiciously regal-looking types, it was generalized that the kitchen, with this much hype, must do a great steak. And of course they do, in particular a killer Porterhouse ($52.00). This bad boy is 24 ounces of rare tender beef with the as-requested toasted peppercorn sauce, mashed potato and mound of the classic creamed spinach.
    Page 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | Next »
    AT A GLANCE
    Prime
    18 St. Thomas St., Toronto, ON
    416-971-9666
    Steak
    Yorkville
    Venue:
    Restaurant
    Hours:
    Daily from 5pm - 11pm
    Price Range:
    $$$$ (Expensive)
    Payment:
    Master Card, Visa, American Express
    THE BUZZ

    IN THE AREA

    8 Reader Reviews

    I am not a picky food snob, but despite a very aggressive rate card, this restaurant delivered neither quality food, competent service or passable ambiance. It would have been over-priced at 1/3 the price ... literally. Perhhaps it's a better dinner option.

    1. Gerry MacKrell's Review :: September 08, 2008
    Gerry MacKrell's Rating: 1 Stars
    Seems to me that the M.Boys reviewer got some 'perks' to write such a bogus review. Not at all what I accepted or my guests. Dim, dreary, not the 5-star hotel they claim to be. The restaurant however, is much better in look with a nice patio outside. Server was prompt and fun. BUT would not go back. This place is missing something. A heart.

    2. K. Blake's Review :: July 10, 2008
    K. Blake's Rating: 1 Stars
    I haven't been in the Windsor Arms Hotel in years because the owner of the hotel is toxic and was very rude to me the last time i visited. That being said the chef does not disappoint and offers a great tasting dining experience. I recommend Prime for dinner meetings and for privacy on a romantic date.

    3. Frank Stanges's Review :: May 27, 2008
    Frank Stanges's Rating: 3 Stars
    I haven't been in the Windsor Arms Hotel in years because the owner of the hotel is toxic and was very rude to me the last time i visited. That being said the chef does not disappoint and offers a great tasting dining experience. I recommend Prime for dinner meetings and for privacy on a romantic date.

    4. Frank Stanges's Review :: May 27, 2008
    Frank Stanges's Rating: 3 Stars
    Nice place, prices somewhat on the higher side but food is good. Service is great.

    5. Anonymous's Review :: March 27, 2008
    Nice place, prices somewhat on the higher side but food is good. Service is great.

    6. Anthony Burgess's Review :: March 27, 2008
    Anthony Burgess's Rating: 4 Stars
    Expensive, pompous and "hotel-restaurant" to the core. But it was wise of Windsor Arms to change things up a bit.

    7. Anonymous's Review :: March 20, 2008
    Expensive, pompous and "hotel-restaurant" to the core. But it was wise of Windsor Arms to change things up a bit.

    8. Ron Blakeley's Review :: March 20, 2008
    Ron Blakeley's Rating: 2 Stars

    Name
    Your City
    Email Address
    Overall Rating
    Your Review
     

    Toronto Restaurants, Toronto Clubs, Toronto Shopping, Toronto Parties, Toronto Galleries, Toronto Theatre, Toronto Club News