Setagaya, NYC

Martiniboys
Martiniboys NYC NYC Restaurants, NYC Dining Guide NYC Clubs and Nightlife NYC Citystock NYC Hotels NYC Hot Tickets NYC Galleries NYC Theatre NYC Movies NYC Products
MBO NYC :: NYC Restaurants & Dining Guide
  • Setagaya

    Back to NYC Restaurants | Scarpetta Seymour Burton

    Review by Ellen Jakobsmeier
    Since ramen became the haute cuisine thanks to Momofuku’s popularity, many other Tokyo-based ramen joints are making the move to NYC. Setagaya is opening their first American outpost but has generated much press since bad-mouthing their Momo competition but duking it out for title of “most authentic ramen joint”.

    Claiming that they use a "traditional recipe using just 10 percent meat and 90 percent ingredients such as dried anchovies, clams, scallops, mushrooms, ginger, garlic, and (the secret weapon) Vietnamese salt, all boiled for five to six hours every morning", Momofuku owner David Chang has since responded to Setagaya with a store front sign stating "Momofuku: 100% Natural Ramen. Made from 90% American Ingredients and 10% of Don't Worry About It." Who will win battle ramen? Make the comparison yourself.
    -E.J.

    1 Reader Reviews

    1. Kimura's Review :: January 13, 2008
    WOW! The most horrible disgusting experience ever!!
    don't even deserve a star.
    Seating is so cramped you can’t take off your jacket because the guy in back of you is literally leaning on your back.

    I had the Shio-Ramen "they claim it’s their best" was the worst ramen I have ever eaten in my life!! I am usually the type of person that drinks the soup to the end but I couldn't finish this one maybe a couple sips. The best description of its flavor would be a bonito flake seaweed tea. no depth in the flavor, noodles were not fully cooked.

    I was extremely disappointed with the results.
    hope they close shop quick or find some chef to redo that POS,
    I'd really hate to see people from NYC going there thinking that is how Japanese Ramen tastes like and spending $12+ for that experience.


    Kimura's Rating: 1 Stars
    Voice your opinion! Submit a reader review for Setagaya. Click here

    Setagaya

    Address

    141 First Avenue, New York, NY

    Phone

    212-529-2740

    Area

    East Village

    Cuisine

    Japanese

    Venue

    Restaurant

    Hours

    Price

    $$$ (Within Reach)

    Payment

    Master Card
    Visa
    American Express
    Diners Club
    Restaurant

    Related Restaurants

    More in Restaurant

    NYC Restaurants, NYC Clubs, NYC Shopping, NYC Parties, NYC Galleries, NYC Theatre, NYC Club News