Dovetail, NYC

Martiniboys
Martiniboys NYC NYC Restaurants, NYC Dining Guide NYC Clubs and Nightlife NYC Citystock NYC Hotels NYC Hot Tickets NYC Galleries NYC Theatre NYC Movies NYC Products
MBO NYC :: NYC Restaurants & Dining Guide
  • Dovetail

    Back to NYC Restaurants | Doug E.'s Chicken and Waffles Down South Café

    To dovetail is to come together harmoniously; an act that NYC patrons will no doubt be experiencing at the appropriately-named Upper West Side hot spot. Dovetail owner and chef, John Fraser, formerly of Compass and Snack Taverna, clearly has way of keeping diners’ taste buds awake and alive; he currently does this with a well-crafted menu that is an attention-grabber from top to bottom.

    Tricky to find, the restaurant is cryptically identified with an easy-to-miss glass door with a subtle "Dovetail" announcing its presence. With Richard Bloch behind the design, the townhouse setting is simple enough, with pastel colorings mixing with exposed brick. The effect is comforting enough, sophisticated with a smattering of woods and earth tones.

    The Euro-fused American menu, in line with Frazer's less-is-more aesthetic, is terse. Most of the time, the ingredients do the talking. We started with clam chowder. In a series of events that was entirely new to me, this turned out to be a thick, creamy soup that was poured into a bowl of clams, chorizo, and potatoes, thus rendering it clam chowder. It was satisfying, if unusually assembled.

    The Brussels sprout leaves with pears, Serrano ham, cauliflower, sunflower seeds, and some sort of truffle-y mayonnaise were an unexpectedly delicious find. The sweetness of the pears and saltiness of the Serrano were beautifully matched. Diminutive and tender, I think that Brussels sprout leaves are poised to be the next great baby salad green; you heard it here first.

    The pistachio-crusted duck with endive, celery root, and truffles was declared edible perfection. The meat was cooked to just-right consistency, its flavor lent additional depth by the earthy accompaniments.
    Page 1 | 2 | 3 | Next »
    AT A GLANCE
    Dovetail
    103 West 77th Street, New York, NY
    212-362-3800
    American
    Upper West Side
    Venue:
    Restaurant
    Hours:
    Mon.-Sun. 5:30 p.m.-11 p.m
    Weekend brunch Sat.-Sun. 11:30 a.m.-3 p.m
    Afternoon tea Fri.-Sun. 11:30 a.m.-3 p.m.
    Price Range:
    $$$ (Within Reach)
    Payment:
    Master Card, Visa, American Express
    THE BUZZ

    IN THE AREA

    5 Reader Reviews

    A beautiful combination of unexpected tastes. Everything we had was very good to exceptional. Nothing disapointed. I say this all in my capacity as a self proclaimed food snob.

    1. Anonymous's Review :: April 29, 2008
    A beautiful combination of unexpected tastes. Everything we had was very good to exceptional. Nothing disapointed. I say this all in my capacity as a self proclaimed food snob.

    2. Howard's Review :: April 29, 2008
    Howard's Rating: 4 Stars
    I'm not sure how comfortable I am to be the first one not to give Dovetail a perfect rating, especially since the food tasted so great, and I really liked the layout. I just don't think the Tasting Menu/Wine Pairing was on par with the price. I also thought that the service was not exceptional- I'm kind of a stickler for eye contact. However, when one is trying to justify why a restaurant received 3 stars instead of 4, you are in for a truly great dining experience.

    3. Anonymous's Review :: March 05, 2008
    I'm not sure how comfortable I am to be the first one not to give Dovetail a perfect rating, especially since the food tasted so great, and I really liked the layout. I just don't think the Tasting Menu/Wine Pairing was on par with the price. I also thought that the service was not exceptional- I'm kind of a stickler for eye contact. However, when one is trying to justify why a restaurant received 3 stars instead of 4, you are in for a truly great dining experience.

    4. Bob Strong's Review :: March 05, 2008
    Bob Strong's Rating: 4 Stars
    simply put -- one of the best dining experiences i've had in New York - everything on the menu I've had has been delicious. The atmosphere is great & the service is fine-tuned. Dovetail is going to be a major player in the restaurant category.

    5. Todd A.'s Review :: February 08, 2008
    Todd A.'s Rating: 4 Stars

    Name
    Your City
    Email Address
    Overall Rating
    Your Review
     

    NYC Restaurants, NYC Clubs, NYC Shopping, NYC Parties, NYC Galleries, NYC Theatre, NYC Club News